Dictionary error not noticed for 99 years

By | May 11, 2010

Those who take the dictionary to be word-perfect should take the time to look a little harder.

It has taken the eye of a Queensland University of Technology physicist to spot a 99-year-old mistake in the Oxford English Dictionary.

The error may be slight, but it’s an error nonetheless, according to Stephen Hughes.

Doctor Hughes claims he has discovered that the dictionary’s definition of the word ‘siphon’ has been incorrect since 1911.

The definition in the Oxford English Dictionary, and many other dictionaries, stated that atmospheric pressure was the force behind a siphon.

But in fact it is the force of gravity at work.

“It is gravity that moved the fluid in a siphon, with the water in the longer downward arm pulling the water up the shorter arm,” Dr Hughes said.

When Dr Hughes stumbled across the mistake he alerted the dictionary’s revision team, which had just completed revising words beginning with the letter ‘R’.

“I thought, ‘Oh good, just in time,’ because S is next,” he said.

The senior lecturer in physics discovered the error after viewing an enormous siphon in South Australia, transferring the equivalent of 4000 Olympic swimming pools from the Murray River system into the depleted Lake Bonney.

“I thought this example would make a great education paper…but in my background research I discovered there was much contention about the definition of the word siphon,” Dr Hughes said.

“I found that almost every dictionary contained the same misconception that atmospheric pressure, not gravity, pushed liquid through the tube of a siphon.” …

via Dictionary error not noticed for 99 years | Stuff.co.nz.

One thought on “Dictionary error not noticed for 99 years

  1. Hunch

    Regarding the Oxford English Dictionary error posted May 11,2010. I’m sure the author is well informed and well intended however it should be noted that a siphon can not be achieved in a vacuum, it requires air pressure or some other gas pressure to maintain the fluid column. Furthermore it can be achieved without the influence of gravity; centrifugal force works well.

    All email received without the proper subject code is considered spam so I would appreciate if you not post or distribute my email address.

    Thank you.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *