Study: Government Services Really Satisfy

By | May 8, 2011

Study Government Services Really Satisfy

People living in countries with governments that have a greater number of social services report being more satisfied with life, according to a study by a Baylor University researcher.

Dr. Patrick Flavin, assistant professor of political science at Baylor, said the effect of state intervention into the economy equaled or exceeded marriage when it came to satisfaction. The study is published in the spring issue of the journal Politics & Policy.

Free market capitalism has been championed by leaders such as the late President Ronald Reagan and former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, while left-leaning political parties and labor movements argue for more government intervention into the market. But scholars have paid little empirical attention to the debate in terms of which leads to more satisfaction among citizens, Flavin said.

Flavin and two other researchers used data from the World Values Survey’s 2005 study. Their research included 10,405 people from 15 advanced industrialized countries who were asked, “All things considered, how satisfied are you with your life as a whole these days?” On a scale of 1 to 10 — with 10 the highest level of satisfaction — the average rating for all respondents was 7.39, with respondents from the United States reporting an average of 7.26.

The study measured government intervention into the economy in four ways: government tax revenue as a percentage of its gross domestic product (GDP), government consumption of GDP, generosity of unemployment benefits and a country’s welfare expenditures as a percentage of GDP.

“In many cases, less government intervention can allow for a more efficient economy, but greater economic efficiency doesn’t necessarily translate into greater contentment with one’s life,” Flavin said. “If you get sick and can’t work or lose your job and there are few social protections in place, you’re more likely to be anxious and less satisfied.”

The findings were consistent regardless of whether respondents were rich or poor and regardless of their political views, Flavin said. The findings rule out alternative explanations including individual characteristics — such as personal health, level of education and marital status — and such national factors as gross domestic product and unemployment rate. ..

via Baylor University || Marketing & Communications || News.

3 thoughts on “Study: Government Services Really Satisfy

  1. Brian

    Sorry xeno, I dont want to troll your wonderful blog, but propaganda pieces like this really tick me off. How can a scientific study claim to accurately measure something as nebulous as th satisfaction of a society? It really serves to illustrate the core fallacy of statism, which is that countries or societies can be measured, and contolled as a single entity, when they are in fact so vastly complex that no state or group of people could even begin to understand them.

    1. Xeno Post author

      Well, sociology is maligned as a soft science, but the sample size was large and the questions seem appropriate to measure a self report of satisfaction. Then again, who can even accurately measure the satisfaction of one person ? Mine changes hour to hour.

Leave a Reply